For fifty years, I’ve been doing theology in a naturalistic framework. I’ve written extensively about transformation technologies, consciousness, meaning-making in an entropic universe, the Opthe Focus Rite, formation processes, and community structure. All of this work rests on a foundation so fundamental I’ve sometimes taken it for granted: three values that function not as arbitrary preferences but as load-bearing requirements for conscious beings who want to generate coherence and meaning without appeal to supernatural authority.
These three values are agape-gratia, wisdom, and reason.
Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
That’s it. Everything else emerges from the disciplined praxis of these three working together. Nothing else is required. Nothing can be removed without losing functionality.
Why These Three?
Each performs a specific, irreplaceable function:
Agape-gratia provides orientation. It directs consciousness toward the welfare and well-being of life, the Earth, and what we call universal good. The result isn’t sentiment or emotion—it’s the fundamental pattern recognition that coherence emerges through connection, not isolation; through service, not domination; through care, not exploitation. Agape-gratia is what keeps consciousness from turning against itself and everything else in pure competitive self-interest.
Wisdom provides constraint. It’s the accumulated, empirical understanding of what actually works and doesn’t work in reality. It is not based on arbitrary rules or divine commands, but rather on tested knowledge about the functioning of consciousness, community, meaning-making, and ecological systems. Wisdom prevents agape-gratia from becoming naive idealism that crashes against reality. It says, "Here are the patterns that produce coherence; here are the patterns that produce collapse.”
Reason provides an application. It’s a powerful tool that works out how to live by agape-gratia and wisdom in specific circumstances. Reason figures out solutions, tests hypotheses, makes distinctions, and solves problems. But—and this is crucial—reason is servant, not master. Unleashed from agape-gratia and wisdom, reason can justify any horror with perfect logic. The Marquis de Sade proved that. Reason must be held on a leash, directed by agape-gratia, and informed by wisdom.
Remove any one of these three, and you lose something essential:
Remove agape-gratia, and you get a competitive nightmare
Remove wisdom, and you get idealism that can’t survive contact with reality
Remove reason, you can’t actually figure out how to live
Not Arbitrary
Here’s what makes this different from “anything goes” relativism: these aren’t arbitrary preferences we’ve chosen because they sound appealing. They’re functional requirements for consciousness to make meaning in an entropic physical universe without destroying itself.
Think of it like gravity. Gravity isn’t a preference. It’s not a divine command. It’s a pattern built into physical reality. Violate it carelessly, and it will kill you—not because it’s angry, but because that’s how it works. You can’t build a stable structure while ignoring gravitational constraints.
Agape-gratia operates the same way. It’s not imposed by sacred imperium from outside. It’s discovered as the actual requirement for coherence to emerge among conscious beings. We don’t have overwhelming empirical evidence for this theory yet because we’ve barely experienced agape-gratia operating consciously, naturally, at scale. Religious traditions wrapped it in supernatural explanations. Competitive culture violates it constantly while claiming it “doesn’t work in the real world.”
But the pattern is there. Test it hard enough—build community on pure competition, orient consciousness entirely toward self-interest, strip away all care for the welfare of others—and watch coherence collapse, meaning disintegrate, and consciousness turn toxic. This is not due to divine retribution; rather, it's because that’s how consciousness actually functions in reality.
What Emerges
From these three values, consciously applied, everything else flows:
Community structure emerges. You don’t need elaborate hierarchies or institutional machinery. Agape-gratia eliminates competitive posturing. Wisdom strips away practices that exist only for tradition or power. Reason finds direct paths.
Ecological responsibility emerges. Agape-gratia, oriented toward “life, the Earth, and universal good,” recognizes that wastefulness harms what you’re serving. Wisdom understands we’re part of ecological patterns, not exempt from them. Reason works out how to live within those constraints.
Formation processes emerge. This doesn’t happen because doctrine requires it, but because reorienting consciousness from competitive to agape-gratia patterns requires real discipline, time, and praxis.
Ethical decision-making emerges. Not from divine command or arbitrary rules, but from asking: Does this align with agape-gratia? What does wisdom tell us about consequences? What does reason reveal about how to proceed?
Even ritual and liturgy emerge. The Opthe Focus Rite is nothing but these three values given body, voice, and rhythm.
Nothing Else Needed
This is radical simplicity, not “liberalism” in the sense of anything goes. This is not "conservatism" in the sense of clinging to past forms. Instead, it is a disciplined, forward-building, and reality-constrained emergence.
We don’t start with an empty library. We have millennia of accumulated human wisdom—scientific knowledge, philosophical traditions, religious practices that generated real transformation, historical examples, and indigenous wisdom about living within ecological limits. All of this can be examined through the lens of these three values: Does this actually work? Does it align with agape-gratia? Does wisdom confirm it? Can reason verify it?
We’re not rejecting wisdom traditions. We’re reverse-engineering them, keeping what passes the test and disregarding what doesn’t.
The Work Ahead
Understanding these three values is conceptually simple. Living by them is the challenging part. The difficulty lies not in the complexity of the framework, but in the reality of their formation. Reorienting consciousness, emotion, and behavior from our evolutionary competitive drives to the patterns of agape-gratia requires discipline, community, and sustained practice.
This is why Opthē must be a living experiment, not just a theory. We need communities actually oriented by these three values, living in them long enough to demonstrate what emerges. It's not about proving the framework to ourselves—those of us who have lived it know it works—but about making the pattern visible to a world that still views agape-gratia as naive idealism rather than a gravity-like reality.
All the theology I have done for the past fifty years flows from these three values. They’ve been operating all along. I’m spotlighting them now because clarity and simplicity matter. Because when people ask, “What is Opthē really about?”
Agape-gratia, wisdom, and reason.
Three values. Nothing more needed. Everything else emerges.